Following previous 23-on-23 events it's clear from feedback that the relatively unstructured formats haven't suited everyone, and a highly structured 'net' style operation (similar to some of the highly coordinated HF DX nets) would no doubt draw similar levels of discontent (probably considerably more, truth be told).
We need to continue to develop the concept and whilst we may never find a format that suits everyone, hopefully we will find one that suits the majority.
One observation that supports the continuation of 23-on-23 is the noticeable increase in the level of activity on 23cm in SE VK4 outside of these events, add to that the level of discussion around improving station capabilities. Directly related to 23-on-23?... maybe not, but the causality is hard to argue. Things are certainly healthier than they were not so long ago.
In my discussions with some of the 23cm operators the one common thread that draws us together is the challenge and opportunity of working more distant stations and not just working across town (sort of supports why you wont find many of us sitting on the local repeaters)
So, with this 23-on-23 just a couple of days after the conclusion of the VHF/UHF Winter Field Day, I'd like to suggest we try something new, an alternative format
And for this event, could we create activity where the focus is to look to the stations outside of the Brisbane metro area There are at least six regularly active stations that would provide suitable, quality 'targets' to our north, south west and south! If we focus on each sequentially the opportunity to work them, and they work us has to be improved. To illustrate a possible approach....
Start 20:00 EST (10:00z) [as this is a 'school' night]
Time slot - Target station
20:00 - 20:15 - VK4BG Hervey Bay (QG64jq)
20:15 - 20:30 - VK4REX: Landsborough (QG63le)
20:30 - 20:45 - VK4ADM: Sippy Downs (QH63mg)
20:45 - 21:00 - VK4KAY: Warwick (QG61AT)
21:00 - 21:15 - VK4DH: Killarney (QG61dq)
21:15 - 21:30 - VK2MAX: Kempsey (QF68JV)
Once a station completes a QSO, they 'stand down' and wait until the next target/time slot.
I can see a number of potential issues with the format... including,
- 1. the lack of AE enhancement during specified time slots (for some or all paths),
2. will require commitment from target stations to be on during allocated slots,
3. will require considerate operating etiquette
4. will require a central coordination approach like VKLogger iChat or a 2m FM repeater to centre and make public any coordination (private channels like email or phone during the event wont work
),
5. the physical spread of stations for which the target station needs to work (many of which will be outside of beam width)
6. will take at least 1.5hours, if not longer to complete
or Your thoughts?
).
I have not unpacked from the field day, hence no participation from me last night. I will be on next month ....